Rekey when the lock works well and you only need old keys to stop working. Replace the lock when the hardware is worn, damaged, or wrong for the door. Rekeying keeps the existing lock and changes which key opens it. A lock change swaps the hardware itself and comes with new keys. Brooklyn Locksmith & Doors does both, so the choice rests on your lock's condition and your goal.
What rekeying actually changes
A rekey is about who holds a working key. A lock change is about the lock itself. The cylinder, the part the key slides into, holds small pins sized to match one key. Rekeying swaps those pins so a new key works and the old ones don't. The worn parts of a failing lock stay in place after a rekey, so a new key won't fix a lock that is wearing out.
Why who holds the old keys matters more than the lock's age
Most people reach this decision because of a change in who has keys. You moved in and don't know how many copies the last occupant or a past contractor kept. A key went missing. A tenant moved out, or an employee left and returned a ring that may not be the only one.
Each of those is a key-access problem, and a lock's age says little about who can open it. An older deadbolt in good working order can be rekeyed and keep doing its job. Replacing the lock also gets rid of old keys, but it throws away hardware that still works.
Three ways to handle the same door
Rekey the existing lock
Rekeying changes the pins and the key. The lock body, handle, and fit in the door stay as they were, so a rekeyed lock works with your existing hardware because it is that hardware. It fits when the lock works well and the goal is controlling who gets in.
Replace it with the same type of lock
A like-for-like replacement swaps the whole lock for a new one that does the same job, such as a deadbolt for a deadbolt, with new keys included. The way the door works stays the same. It fits when the hardware is worn or damaged but the type of lock still suits the door.
Upgrade to a different type
Sometimes the door calls for a different kind of lock: a deadbolt where there was only a knob lock, or a smart lock that opens with a code or a phone. That changes how you get in, not just which key works. A different lock may not fit the existing holes in the door, so the door becomes part of the decision. Brooklyn Locksmith & Doors also installs smart locks if that is where you are leaning.
Signs the lock needs replacing, not a new key
Rekeying only touches the pins. It does not repair a worn mechanism or a bolt that won't reach. Things you can check at the door yourself:
- The key needs jiggling or force before it turns.
- The cylinder or the whole lock wobbles or spins in the door when you use it.
- The deadbolt stops short or grinds as it moves.
- Visible damage: pry marks, bent trim, a cracked cylinder, or a loose strike plate, the metal plate on the frame that the bolt slides into.
- The lock no longer suits how the door is used, such as an entry door with only a knob lock.
If the bolt moves freely with the door open but drags once the door closes, the door or strike plate may be out of line rather than the lock failing. Mention that when you call, since it points to a different fix.
What to have ready before a lock change or rekey
These details shape the job for a house, an apartment, a storefront, or a multi-unit building:
- How many doors, and which ones: front, back, unit, side, or storefront.
- Residential or commercial, and in a building, whether shared doors like the lobby are included.
- The lock type on each door: deadbolt, knob or lever lock, or a mortise lock, which is a lock body set into a pocket in the door's edge and common on storefronts.
- Whether one key should open several doors, or different people need different keys.
- How many keys you need.
- Anything you noticed in the checks above, and whether any door is headed for a smart lock.
Next step for your doors
Once you know whether you want new keys, new hardware, or a mix across different doors, call Brooklyn Locksmith & Doors at (347) 357-0985, any hour of the day. The business takes jobs across Brooklyn, including Williamsburg, Bushwick, Crown Heights, Park Slope, Brooklyn Heights, and Bay Ridge. If you are still undecided, describe how the lock behaves and why the old keys concern you. Those two answers point toward one option or the other.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to rekey if I only lost one key?
Losing one key raises the same question as losing several: can you account for it? If the key was on a ring with anything tied to your address, or you don't know where it went, rekeying the lock makes that lost key stop working. If you know the key was destroyed, there is less reason to change anything.
Can several locks be rekeyed to use one key?
Several locks can often be set to one key, which is called keying alike. Keying alike works when the locks share a keyway, the shape of the key slot and blade. Locks from different makers often use different keyways, so one lock may need replacing before a single key opens them all.
Is a lock change or rekey something I should do when a tenant moves out?
When a tenant moves out, the practical concern is that the tenant, and anyone given copies, may still hold working keys. Rekeying the unit's locks cuts those keys off and keeps sound hardware in place. If the locks are worn or you want a different type for the next tenant, a lock change handles both at once.
Need a locksmith in Brooklyn? We come to you -- 24/7.
(347) 357-0985 - Call Now