Back to all articles

A spare key belongs with a person you rely on or in a spot with controlled access, and as few people as possible should know where it is. A key under the mat or above the door frame is the weakest choice. Rather than asking where to hide a spare, ask who can reach it and whether you would know if they used it.

Is it safe to hide a spare key outside the door?

A spare key hidden outside the door is the weakest option because it is a copy of access with no owner. Anyone who finds it can use it and put it back, and nothing tells you it happened.

Hiding spots near a door tend to be the same few places: the mat, a planter, the top of the frame. Those are the first places a stranger checks. You also reach for the key in view of the street, so anyone watching learns where it is.

A spare held by a person, or kept behind a door you already control, has someone answering for it.

Count the spares you already have

Take stock before you place anything. A plan for two spares falls apart if there are really five.

Which doors a key opens matters when locks are keyed alike, meaning several locks share one key. A single lost spare then opens more than one door.

A copy nobody can account for changes the plan. A better spot for future spares does nothing about one that is already out there.

A household usually needs one dependable backup. A workplace needs several people with different access, plus a record of who holds what.

Picking a spot for a home spare

For a home spare, the realistic choices are a person nearby, a secured spot inside the home or building, or a lockable key holder. Each one trades speed of access against exposure.

Who is reachable comes first. A neighbor or relative close by works only if they answer the phone and are usually around when you come and go. How long a lockout could last comes next. A child or pet inside makes a slow route to the spare much harder to accept.

Then there is who could watch the spot being used. A spare in a shared lobby or mailroom is only as controlled as that space. A lockable holder by the door is harder to open than a planter is to lift, but it is still outside and in view. An open hiding place outside wins on speed and loses on everything else.

Spare keys at a business or across several units

Business spares should sit with the owner or a manager, or in a locked spot inside the premises such as an office key cabinet. A sign-out log can be a plain notebook, as long as it shows which key, who took it, and when.

Keep the front door, storefront, back rooms, and gates on separate keys where you can, so the person who opens in the morning does not also carry the stockroom key. Master-level access, meaning one key that opens many locks, should sit with as few people as possible.

Tag keys with a code that only means something on your list. A tag with the street address tells a finder exactly where to go. Property managers holding keys for several units need the same setup on a larger scale.

Staff changes are the natural review point. When someone leaves or changes roles, check what they held and collect it before you update the log.

Handing over a spare, and when a missing one means a rekey

Before a spare changes hands, write down four things.

  1. Who has it, by name
  2. Which door or doors it opens
  3. When it is due back, or that it is ongoing
  4. Where the record lives, so you can find it later

When a spare cannot be accounted for, a new hiding place will not solve the problem. A rekey changes the pins inside the lock cylinder so the old keys no longer turn it. A lock change replaces the hardware. Either way, the missing copy stops opening that door, whether or not anyone ever finds it.

If your inventory turns up a gap, call Brooklyn Locksmith & Doors at (347) 357-0985 about a rekey or lock change at your home or business in Brooklyn. If you are locked out with no spare in reach, the business also handles emergency lockouts 24/7.

Frequently asked questions

Is a lockbox or key holder safer than hiding a key outside?

A lockbox or key holder adds a barrier that a key under the mat lacks, because someone needs the code to open it. It is still outside and visible, so it does not make a spare safe on its own. Anyone who learns the code holds a copy in practice. Change the code once people who knew it no longer need access, and open the holder where passersby cannot see the code.

How many spare keys is too many?

Spare keys become too many once you can no longer name who holds each one. For a household, one or two well-placed spares usually cover a lost key or a key locked inside. At a workplace, roles should set the count, not convenience. If the number of copies keeps growing and the record does not, the spares have outpaced your control of them.

Should a landlord or property manager keep a spare for each unit?

A property manager who keeps unit spares should treat them as controlled copies: one locked place, a coded tag on each key instead of the unit address, and a log entry each time a key leaves. Store unit keys apart from keys for common doors and gates, so pulling one unit key never puts building-wide access in the same hand. A change of occupant is a good moment to check which copies are still out.

Should I rekey if I can't remember who has a copy?

A rekey is worth considering when you cannot name who has a copy. If you can name every holder and get the copies back, collecting them may be enough. If even one copy is unknown, the lock it opens is the one to address, and with locks keyed alike that can mean several doors. Start a simple record when the new keys go out, so each spare has a known holder.

Need a locksmith in Brooklyn? We come to you -- 24/7.

(347) 357-0985 - Call Now