Neither a key lockbox nor a keypad lock is better for every door. A lockbox holds a real key behind a code, so it suits short, occasional access by few people while the existing lock stays untouched. A keypad lock opens the door with a code, so it suits repeated or multi-person access where you want to change who gets in without moving a key.
A key in a box versus a code on the door
The difference between a key lockbox and a keypad lock is what you hand over. A lockbox code opens a small box, and inside is an ordinary key that the visitor then uses on your door. A keypad lock code works the door itself. Nothing physical changes hands, and nothing is left behind when the visitor goes.
The key lockbox: simple to add, harder to close out
A key lockbox is a small locked container, usually metal, that holds a key. It opens with a combination of buttons or dials. The box mounts near the door, either screwed to a wall or post or hung by its shackle, the U-shaped loop found on a padlock, around a railing or pipe. Your door and lock stay exactly as they are.
The visitor opens the box, takes the key, lets themselves in, and is meant to put the key back on the way out. That last step depends on them. If the key leaves in someone's pocket, the next visitor finds an empty box.
The bigger point is what remains afterward. The key in a lockbox is a real key, and anyone who held it could have it copied. Changing the box code controls the box, not the door. To fully end access, you need the key back and confidence it was never duplicated, or the lock rekeyed, which means changing the pins inside the cylinder so old keys stop turning it. A basic combination box also keeps no record of who opened it.
The keypad lock: the code is the key
A keypad lock is door hardware with a number pad. The visitor enters a code and the lock withdraws its bolt directly. There is no separate key to fetch or return.
Because access is a code rather than an object, many keypad locks let you give different people their own codes and delete one without affecting the others. How many codes a lock holds, and whether you change them at the keypad or another way, depends on the model, so confirm that before you buy.
The trade-off is that the door has to accept the hardware. The holes through the door, the door's thickness, and the alignment of the bolt with the strike plate in the frame all have to suit the lock. Most keypad locks run on batteries, so you need a plan for a dead battery. Some keep a key cylinder as a backup and some do not. If yours does, that key is still something to keep track of.
Fitting a keypad lock to a home or business door falls under smart lock installation, which Brooklyn Locksmith & Doors handles.
Which one fits your door and your visitors?
A few questions about your own situation usually settle it.
- How long and how often. A plumber for two days is not the same as a cleaner every week for a year. Brief, rare access leans toward a lockbox, and ongoing access leans toward a keypad.
- How many different people. One contractor is easy to keep track of. Rotating crews, guests, or staff mean more people who once held the key or knew a code.
- Whether the code will travel. A contractor may pass a code to a helper. A keypad code can be deleted afterward, but a lockbox code also gave the helper the key.
- Whether the door can take new hardware. A damaged door edge, a worn frame, or holes that do not match a keypad lock may need work first or point you toward a lockbox.
- What kind of door it is. A house, a rental unit with a new guest every few days, and a shop door used by staff each see different traffic. Frequent turnover favors a keypad and a fresh code per guest.
- Whether a rekey follows. If a lockbox key passes through many hands, plan on rekeying when the arrangement ends and count that as part of the lockbox choice.
If you are not sure your door can take a keypad, or you want a lock rekeyed after a lockbox arrangement ends, call Brooklyn Locksmith & Doors at (347) 357-0985 and talk through the door you have.
Frequently asked questions
If I change a lockbox code, does that stop someone who copied the key?
No. A lockbox code only controls the box. A copied key works the door lock directly, and changing the code leaves that lock exactly as it was. Shutting out a possible copy means changing the lock itself, either by rekeying the cylinder or replacing the lock. A rekey stops every old copy at once, including copies you never knew existed.
Can a keypad lock be installed on a door that already has a deadbolt?
A keypad lock can often go on a door that already has a deadbolt. Many keypad deadbolts are made to replace a standard deadbolt using the existing holes, and some keypad handle sets work alongside a separate deadbolt. The fit depends on the hole sizes, the door thickness, and where the bolt meets the frame, so measure the door before buying.
What happens to a keypad lock if the power runs out?
When the batteries in a keypad lock die, the keypad stops responding and the lock stays in whatever position it was in. Many models warn of low batteries ahead of time, and some allow temporary power at the keypad or keep a key cylinder as a backup. Which of these a given lock offers depends on the model.
When should I rekey after a contractor or guest has had access?
Rekeying makes sense when a physical key left your control and you cannot be sure it was never copied, such as a lockbox key used by several workers or a key returned late. If access was only a keypad code you have since deleted, a rekey matters only if someone also held the backup key.
Need a locksmith in Brooklyn? We come to you -- 24/7.
(347) 357-0985 - Call Now